Death Penalty in America, Legal 485

February 6, 2003

Group discussion questions

  1. Finish any questions that your group didn’t get to on Tuesday.
  2. Bedau says on p. 29 (2nd paragraph) “...it may come as a surprise to those who believe the death penalty is blatantly racist in character to learn that black murderers are slightly less likely to end up on death row than their white counterparts.”  Do you think this means racism has been eliminated from the criminal justice system?  Later in that paragraph, Bedau says, “Killers of blacks (whether white or black) rarely get sentenced to death, much less executed, whereas killers of whites (whether white or black) are far more at risk.”  How do you account for this difference?  Be specific.
  3. Look at the numbers in “Risk of Execution,” pp. 31-33.  Make sure that everyone in the group understands what the numbers represent.  How do you account for the fact that so few murderers are executed?  Be specific.  Do you see these numbers as supporting imposition of the death penalty or opposing it?  Explain.
  4. Think back to your reading and discussion about capital punishment in the colonial era and in the 1800s.  Thinking as a sociologist would, what do you see as the purpose or function of capital punishment in their culture?  Be specific.
  5. Still thinking as a sociologist, what do you think is the purpose or function of capital punishment in our culture today?  Do you see any similarities?  Be specific.